Top-Rated Appraisers Near You in Hamilton County, IN

ELM PROPERTY GROUP

3 EMPLOYEES. ALL LICENSED &/OR CERTIFIED REAL ESTATE APPRAISERS. COST DETERMINED BY FLAT RATE. ASK ABOUT ANGIE'S LIST 15% DISCOUNT.

Read more about ELM PROPERTY GROUP

Medallion Appraisals, LLC

Certified Residential Appraiser completing all residential assignments.

Read more about Medallion Appraisals, LLC

AdvantEdge Valuation Services
Guhl & Associates, LLC

Guhl & Associates, LLC is a real estate valuation firm, performing appraisals for home owners, real estate agents, lawyers, accountants and private parties. We pride ourselves on our high quality, diligently prepared, and thoroughly readable appraisal reports. You can count on our 21 years of experience, ethics, competence, diligence, and delivery. Our business is built on these values. When it comes to making important real estate investment decisions, the more you know, the better decision you can make!

Read more about Guhl & Associates, LLC

Knight Appraisal Services

Knight Appraisal Services has over a decade of experience appraising residential real estate in Central Indiana.Knight Appraisal Services has completed appraisals for many local banks including Flagstar, Huntington and PNC just to name a few.With thousands of appraisals completed, Knight Appraisal Services has the knowledge & expertise you can rely upon for your appraisal needs.Give us a call today for a free quote on our services

Read more about Knight Appraisal Services

AMERICAN STANDARD APPRAISALS

ONE PERSON OPERATION. NO SUBS. CHARGES BY THE JOB.

Read more about AMERICAN STANDARD APPRAISALS

Indy Preferred Appraisal Group
HAYDEN GROUP

Appraiser FAQs

A home appraiser is a qualified professional trained to determine the fair market value of a property. The appraisal typically includes an in-depth evaluation of the home’s overall condition, size, location, neighborhood market trends, and comparable property sales in the area. Banks and lenders often request appraisals during mortgage approvals, but they are also useful for refinancing, divorce settlements, or tax assessments. Appraisers provide an unbiased report that ensures a property is neither undervalued nor overpriced.

The cost of a home appraisal typically ranges between $300 and $450 for a standard single-family home. However, more complex properties, such as multi-family homes or luxury estates, may have higher fees, often exceeding $600. Factors like location, the property’s square footage, unique features, and the appraiser’s experience can influence the final cost. Always request a clear explanation of pricing when selecting an appraiser to avoid hidden fees.

In Hamilton County, you can find licensed appraisers through official real estate or appraisal boards, professional organizations like the Appraisal Institute, or referrals from local realtors and mortgage lenders. Ensure the professional is certified by checking their credentials with your state licensing board. Many states provide online databases to verify appraisers' licensure and qualifications. For additional help, browse databases like the National Registry of Appraisers: National Appraiser Licensing Registry.

Several factors can impact a home’s appraisal value, including:

  • Location: Proximity to schools, amenities, and neighborhood reputation.
  • Property condition: The state of the roof, foundation, and major systems like HVAC or plumbing.
  • Recent upgrades or renovations: Modern kitchens and bathrooms often add value.
  • Market conditions: Supply and demand trends in the local real estate market.
  • Comparable sales: The selling price of similar homes in the immediate area. Appraisers weigh these factors together, focusing on elements that have the most influence on value.

A home appraisal typically takes 1–3 weeks from scheduling to receiving the final report. The on-site property inspection usually takes 1–2 hours, depending on the size and condition of the home. After the inspection, the appraiser spends additional time analyzing comparable properties, local market trends, and property specifics before delivering the report. If you're working within a tight schedule—like during a home purchase—follow up with the appraiser to ensure timelines are met.

To prepare for a home appraisal:

  1. Clean and declutter: First impressions matter, so present a well-maintained space.
  2. Make necessary repairs: Fix obvious issues like leaky faucets or broken windows.
  3. List recent upgrades: Summarize any home improvements (e.g., new HVAC, added deck) for the appraiser.
  4. Provide access to all areas: Ensure the attic, basement, and garage are accessible.
  5. Gather documentation: Prepare property records like the deed, previous appraisals, or tax assessments. Being proactive can lead to a smoother process and can ensure your home is appraised at its correct value.

When selecting a home appraiser, ask these essential questions:

  • Are you state-certified or licensed?
  • How many years of experience do you have in appraising properties like mine?
  • Can you provide references or reviews from past clients?
  • What is your typical turnaround time for reports?
  • How do you calculate your fees, and are there additional charges?
  • What does your appraisal report include? These questions can help you gauge the appraiser's expertise and ensure they meet your needs.

Watch for these warning signs when hiring a home appraiser:

  • Lack of certification or license: Ensure they are fully qualified and verified by state boards.
  • Too-good-to-be-true offers: Extremely low fees could signal inexperience or poor-quality service.
  • Rushed appraisals: If they promise an unusually quick process, their report may lack thorough research.
  • Limited local knowledge: An appraiser unfamiliar with Hamilton County or area market trends may not provide an accurate valuation. Always verify credentials and request a sample report to assess their professionalism.

Home appraisals are generally very accurate, as they are conducted by trained professionals following industry standards. However, they can vary slightly depending on the appraiser's experience, the availability of comparable sales, and fluctuating market conditions. Errors can sometimes occur if critical home features are overlooked or if the home’s condition is misrepresented. To ensure accuracy, provide the appraiser with all relevant home details and ask for clarification if any information in the final report seems incorrect.

Yes, certified appraisers follow strict professional standards, primarily outlined by the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP). USPAP sets guidelines for ethics, competency, and performance, ensuring reports are unbiased and reliable. In addition, most appraisers belong to professional organizations, like the Appraisal Institute, which impose further ethical and quality standards. To learn more about these standards, visit the Appraisal Foundation’s website at The Appraisal Foundation.

Reviews for Appraisers

Accurate Appraisal Saved Our Sale
We were in a pinch when the buyer’s lender required a second appraisal just days before closing. The appraiser was at our Kansas City home the next morning, and their detailed report smoothed everything out. Thanks to their swift response, we closed on time without losing the buyer.
Emily R.
Ratings icon
Fast & Fair Appraisal Process
After a storm damaged part of our property, we needed an updated appraisal urgently for the insurance claim. Living in Austin, it was hard to find someone available, but they fit us in within 48 hours. Their precise valuation maximized our payout, covering all the repairs in full.
James L.
Ratings icon
Quick and Seamless Refinance Appraisal
To lock in a lower interest rate, we needed a home valuation ASAP. This appraiser showed up right on time, provided a clear and comprehensive report, and made the whole refinancing process stress-free. With their help, we're now saving over $300 a month on our mortgage!
Sophia T.
Ratings icon

Why Hire Appraisers on The Builder Market?

Find Top-Rated Appraisers Near You

Learn More about Our Contributors

Maria Vierra avatar

Maria VierraEditor

Maria Vierra is the lead designer at Vierra Fine Homes, bringing over two decades of experience in high-end residential design and construction. Her expertise and attention to detail ensure every project meets the highest standards of excellence, blending functionality with aesthetic appeal.

Brett Taylor avatar

Brett TaylorAuthor

Brett Taylor is the co-founder of The Builder Market and a visionary entrepreneur in the home services and construction industries. With a passion for innovation, Brett has played a pivotal role in revolutionizing how professionals and homeowners connect and collaborate.

This page was last updated on Jun 17, 2025, 12:56:44 AM