Top-Rated Drywall & Plaster Pros Near You in Sag Harbor, NY

Ingo Sumner Ceiling & Drywall

We transform ceilings and walls into finished products that will not only meet the highest expectations, but add value to your investment upon resale. We can resolve any difficult issues that do unexpectedly arise, or address faulty workmanship on prior work.?

Read more about Ingo Sumner Ceiling & Drywall

Kelley Home Services LLC

Family owned & operated full service construction company. License #kellehs005lz. If we don't offer the service you need, we will gladly provide a qualified referral.

Read more about Kelley Home Services LLC

Frank's Plastering

We pride our company on reliability, great communication, integrity, and quality work. We are experts in our trade and will do our best to keep you as educated as we can on your particular task or project. We look forward to earning your business!

Read more about Frank's Plastering

Bill Livingston Inc

We have won the Super Service award in drywall for the past nine years including 2018. Our passion is doing drywall repairs and popcorn removal and texturing. I have over 30 years experience working on all phases of ceiling and wall work.. As you can see by our reports, we take great pride in every single job we do. AT THIS TIME, I ONLY SERVICE NORTH PINELLAS COUNTY. CLEARWATER-TARPON SPRINGS

Read more about Bill Livingston Inc

Melnick & Sons LLC
Pete M Drywall Inc
Dan Bozzo Spackling

Dan Bozzo Spackling Nesconset, NY, 11767 (631) 839-3948 Our drywall specialists are the most preferred in the Nesconset, NY area. Call now and reach Dan Bozzo Spackling. Get the service you deserve! Drywall Taping, Local Drywall Contractors, Local Sheetrock Contractors, Skim Coating, Drywall Repair, Spackling Services Lake Grove NY;St James NY;Village of the Branch NY;Islandia NY;Head of the Harbor NY Drywall Service, Skim Coat, Drywall Spackle, Sheetrock Contractors, Drywall Contractors http://danbozzospa

Read more about Dan Bozzo Spackling

Dream Remodelers, Inc.

Dream Remodeling is a fully licensed and insured local painting company. We’re backed by the experience that comes from successfully completing more than 7,000 projects. We pride ourselves on customer service and measure our success based on your satisfaction. At Dream Remodeling, we understand that selecting the right local painting company can be challenging. Many times the difference between acceptable and exceptional is found in the details. That is why we have developed a comprehensive 20 Step Process

Read more about Dream Remodelers, Inc.

Intini Construction Services, Inc.

Intini Construction Services, Inc. has over 20 years of experience providing the following industrial and commercial construction services throughout New Jersey and Eastern Pennsylvania: Commercial Drywall Contractors, Wood & Metal Framing, Acoustical Ceiling Tile Installation, Wood & Metal Truss Construction and Door, Frame & Hardware Installation. We deliver quality construction services for all types of commercial/retail projects, including strip malls, banks, class A office space, hospitals, doctors' o

Read more about Intini Construction Services, Inc.

Vettco Construction Corp.

Vettco Construction has been in business for 16 years with a management team with over 75 years of combined experience in interior construction. Our success is built on the fundamental principles of integrity, professionalism, and an uncompromising commitment to quality. Vettco Construction is a privately owned corporation that was built from the ground up, one successful project at a time. We are proud of our ever expanding list of referrals provided by clients we have serviced in the past. Vettco Construc

Read more about Vettco Construction Corp.

About Drywall & Plaster Pros in Sag Harbor, NY

When it comes to drywall and plaster services in Sag Harbor, understanding the unique characteristics of the area is essential for achieving flawless, long-lasting results. As experienced contractors, we’ve worked on everything from historic homes with aging lath-and-plaster walls in the village’s renowned historic district to modern waterfront properties that demand moisture-resistant drywall solutions. Sag Harbor’s coastal climate, with its high humidity and seasonal temperature shifts, can lead to cracking in plaster finishes and swelling at drywall seams, making professional installation and repair crucial to maintaining the integrity of your walls and ceilings.

For older homes in Sag Harbor, plaster restoration often requires adherence to historical preservation guidelines, especially in protected neighborhoods. These projects demand skilled craftsmanship to match original textures and finishes while complying with local permitting requirements set by the Town of Southampton Building Department. Additionally, fire-rated assemblies and soundproofing solutions are frequently necessary for multi-family dwellings and condo units, ensuring compliance with modern building codes and enhancing safety and comfort for residents.

Drywall installation in Sag Harbor typically costs between $1.50 and $4.00 per square foot, while plaster repair or restoration can range from $8 to $20 per square foot depending on the complexity of the project. Whether you’re patching a crack, upgrading a space, or restoring a historic treasure, our expertise in Sag Harbor’s unique architectural needs ensures your home is in the best possible hands. Contact us today to discuss your project and receive a customized quote!

Drywall & Plaster FAQs

The cost of drywall and plaster services can vary based on the size and scope of the project, but here are some general nationwide ranges to help you plan:

  • Drywall Installation: $1.50–$3.50 per square foot, depending on materials and labor.
  • Plaster Repair: $200–$800 for small to medium repairs.
  • Drywall Patching or Repairs: $75–$300 per patch, depending on the size.
  • Texturing Services: $400–$1,200 for an average-sized room, depending on complexity.

For a more accurate estimate, get a detailed quote tailored to your home. It's always helpful to provide contractors with the dimensions of the space and any specific details about unique finishes or textures you want.

Finding reliable drywall and plaster pros in Sag Harbor can be straightforward if you follow these steps:

  1. Check online reviews on platforms like Google, Yelp, or Houzz to get a sense of a company's reputation.
  2. Ask for recommendations from friends, neighbors, or local community groups.
  3. Verify licensing and insurance. Most states require contractors to be licensed. You can look up license validation through your state's licensing board.
  4. Get multiple quotes. Comparing at least three estimates ensures you're getting competitive pricing.
  5. Review past work. Ask for photos or references from previous jobs to ensure they fit your quality expectations.

While DIY plaster repair is an option for small cracks, hiring a professional offers several benefits:

  • Expertise: Professionals have the skills to handle complex repairs, such as fixing structural issues or matching intricate textures.
  • Tools and Materials: Many repairs require specialized tools and high-quality materials not typically found in a DIY kit.
  • Time Savings: Tackling repairs yourself can take days or weeks to complete, while a pro can often finish in hours.
  • Durability: Proper professional repairs are less likely to develop further issues, saving you from costly fixes down the road.

For critical areas like ceilings or detailed decorative plaster, a professional's touch is especially important.

To ensure you’re hiring the right professional, ask these key questions:

  1. Are you licensed and insured?
  2. How many years of experience do you have with drywall and plaster work?
  3. Can you provide references or examples of similar projects?
  4. What is included in the estimate?
  5. How do you handle mess and clean-up?
  6. What is your timeline for completing the project?
  7. Is a warranty included with your work?

These questions help gauge the contractor’s professionalism, reliability, and attention to detail.

Installing drywall in a standard-sized room (10x12 feet) generally takes 1-2 days for professionals to complete, depending on factors such as:

  • Room preparation: Moving furniture and prepping the area adds to the timeline.
  • Number of walls vs. ceilings: Ceilings take longer due to height and angles.
  • Finishing steps: Taping, mudding, and sanding typically require 24 hours of drying time between coats.

If texturing or painting is included, expect the project to take an additional 2-3 days for proper curing.

During a drywall repair project, you can expect the following steps:

  1. Assessment: The contractor examines the damaged area to determine the repair strategy.
  2. Preparation: They’ll protect surrounding areas with drop cloths or plastic sheeting and ensure safety measures are in place.
  3. Repair Work: Small cracks and holes are typically patched, while larger sections may require new drywall installation.
  4. Sanding and Finishing: The repaired area is smoothed over to ensure it blends seamlessly with the surrounding surface.
  5. Cleanup: Professionals will leave your space clean and free of dust.

Yes, drywall and plaster contractors are typically required to hold a valid license, but the requirements vary by state and locality. Licensing ensures that the contractor meets basic standards for safety and competence.

For example: You can verify licensing requirements through organizations like National Association of State Contractors Licensing Agencies or your local building department. Always ask contractors to provide their license number and verify it before beginning work.

Determining whether you need a repair or full replacement depends on the condition of the drywall:

  • Repair: Small holes, cracks, or dents can be easily patched or sealed.
  • Replacement: Opt for this when the drywall shows widespread water damage, mold, or structural issues.

A professional assessment can help you decide. Repairs are more cost-effective but only address limited damage, while replacement ensures long-term durability.

Most professional drywall and plaster contractors include cleanup as part of their service. This typically involves:

  • Removing dust and debris generated during cutting, sanding, and texturing.
  • Disposing of old materials and scraps.
  • Wiping down adjacent surfaces to ensure your home is left in good condition.

Be sure to confirm their cleanup policy before starting the job to avoid misunderstandings.

Yes, professional plaster contractors in Sag Harbor can often handle historic plaster restoration. These projects typically require:

  • Specialized techniques to match the original style and texture.
  • High-quality materials to replicate traditional methods like lime-based plasters.
  • Attention to detail to preserve the character of historical homes.

Look for professionals with experience in historical restoration and make sure they can provide examples of similar past projects.

Reviews for Drywall & Plaster Pros

Ceiling Repair, Crisis Averted
After a plumbing mishap left a hole in our dining room ceiling, I was frantic to get it fixed before hosting family. Within 24 hours of posting my project, a drywall pro arrived, repaired the damage, and matched the paint perfectly! The dining room looked good as new, and I didn’t have to cancel our plans.
Lisa R.
Ratings icon
Smooth Walls, No Hassle
Moving into a 1950s home in Denver revealed countless cracks in the plaster walls. I found a skilled pro through the platform who not only fixed everything in record time but also kept the costs way under my budget. Our freshly smoothed walls made the space feel modern again, and the whole process was impressively seamless.
Mark B.
Ratings icon
Basement Transformation in Days
Our unfinished basement had exposed drywall seams that made it unlivable. A fantastic contractor reached out through this service and tackled the job quickly. Now, we finally have a family room everyone loves to hang out in, with zero delays or unexpected charges.
Sophia L.
Ratings icon

Why Hire Drywall & Plaster Pros on The Builder Market?

Find Top-Rated Drywall & Plaster Pros Near You

Related Services Near You

Learn More about Our Contributors

Maria Vierra avatar

Maria VierraEditor

Maria Vierra is the lead designer at Vierra Fine Homes, bringing over two decades of experience in high-end residential design and construction. Her expertise and attention to detail ensure every project meets the highest standards of excellence, blending functionality with aesthetic appeal.

Brett Taylor avatar

Brett TaylorAuthor

Brett Taylor is the co-founder of The Builder Market and a visionary entrepreneur in the home services and construction industries. With a passion for innovation, Brett has played a pivotal role in revolutionizing how professionals and homeowners connect and collaborate.

This page was last updated on Dec 5, 2025, 5:23:50 AM