Top-Rated General Contractors Near You in Shelter Island Heights, NY

STL Design & Build
(*)(*)(*)(*)(*)4.9 (47 Reviews)

STL Design and Build is a full-service design-build firm dedicated to transforming your vision into reality. With expertise spanning residential and commercial projects, we seamlessly integrate innovative design with meticulous construction to create spaces that are both visually stunning and highly functional. Our experienced team collaborates closely with you from concept through completion, ensuring every detail aligns with your unique goals. We employ the latest industry techniques and sustainable pract

Read more about STL Design & Build

4 U Roofing & Construction

4 U Roofing is a locally owned and operated company that specializes in asphalt shingle roofing, painting, siding & drywall install and repairs for new and existing homes. We take pride in the quality of our work and our commitment to outstanding results. Please allow us the opportunity to earn your business!

Read more about 4 U Roofing & Construction

2atara Design.Build LLC

Small design/build company specializing in sustainable design.

Read more about 2atara Design.Build LLC

A. DeVito & Son, Inc.

We are a 5th generation family owned and operated business that has been serving Westchester and Putnam Counties for over 100 years. As a general contractor we specialize in both large and small scale residential and commercial projects such as new home construction, additions, remodels/renovations as well as full land development. Our commercial resume includes everything from small professional office fit ups to medical/dental facilities, Class-1000 Clean Laboratories, dog kennels and vet hospitals. Pr

Read more about A. DeVito & Son, Inc.

Addisum Home Restoration

As Cleveland, Ohio's leading home remodeler, Addisum Home Restoration specializes in all aspects of home improvement. We also specialize in insurance work such as fire, smoke or water damage. With over 15 years of residential construction experience, make Addisum your 1st and last call to get expert home improvement done right.

Read more about Addisum Home Restoration

Forerunner Creations

We are an owner-operated metal fabrication company, specializing in the restoration and replication of 18th and 19th century cast and forged metalwork. Working in cooperation with homeowners and preservationists we achieve historically accurate and beautiful finished products that are compliant with all federal and city Landmark criteria. Our company is a recognized contractor with the NYC Landmarks Conservancy. In historic districts, fences and handrails made of cast-iron and wrought-iron differ in appea

Read more about Forerunner Creations

GianFranco Contracting

Our experienced Staten Island Contractor team is committed to handling every job, whether small or large, with complete dedication and an eye to quality. We believe in giving our customers the best value possible. So, although you’ll get top-notch materials and workmanship, you’ll find that our prices are extremely competitive. Don’t just take our word on this – we urge you to talk to our customers and compare prices. We buy in volume-direct from the manufacturer, many based on Staten Island, at special di

Read more about GianFranco Contracting

Gotham City Builders Inc

Design-Build Project Delivery Home Remodeling Kitchens & Baths Roofs, Floors, Windows, Siding, Brick Retail and Office Build Outs Custom Fabrications Insurance Claim Projects Landmark Projects Decks & Patios

Read more about Gotham City Builders Inc

G & P Remodeling, Corp

Remodeler, specializing in KITCHENS and BATHROOMS, putting heart and soul into every last detail. We are your preferred designer, custom remodeler and repairer whether this from wood floors to heat floors, you name it! We are fully insured, based in Island Park, NY, poudly serving homeowners from Nassau, Suffolk and the Five Boroughs, as well as other areas, managed by people with more than 10 years of experience.

Read more about G & P Remodeling, Corp

Daniel\u2019s Waterproofing

Safeguard your home from potential water damage by contacting Daniels’ Waterproofing for quality basement waterproofing services in Cleveland. As a locally owned and operated business, we’re proud to serve our community and protect them from water damage. When customers contact our company, they can rest assured they will receive personalized attention and customized waterproofing plans. All our technicians are licensed and insured for your protection. We back our services with over 40 years of experience a

Read more about Daniel\u2019s Waterproofing

About General Contractors in Shelter Island Heights, NY

When it comes to construction and remodeling projects in Shelter Island Heights, working with an experienced general contractor is essential. This picturesque hamlet, nestled within Shelter Island, offers a unique blend of historic homes, coastal cottages, and modern properties, each presenting its own set of challenges. From preserving the charm of older structures to adhering to strict zoning regulations, every project here requires a deep understanding of local guidelines and environmental factors.

One of the key complexities of building or renovating in Shelter Island Heights lies in its coastal location. The proximity to water means that contractors must account for flood zones, high humidity, and the potential for salt air corrosion when selecting materials and planning designs. Additionally, the Town of Shelter Island’s Building Department enforces rigorous permitting processes to ensure compliance with zoning laws, environmental preservation ordinances, and FEMA floodplain requirements. Navigating these regulations is critical to keeping your project on schedule and within budget.

Homeowners in Shelter Island Heights can expect general contractor costs to range from $250 to $400 per square foot for high-quality renovations, with new construction often exceeding $500 per square foot depending on finishes and complexity. Whether you're restoring a historic home in the Heights or building a custom retreat near the shore, partnering with a contractor who understands the area’s unique demands ensures your project is executed with precision and care.

General Contractor FAQs

A general contractor oversees construction projects, managing all aspects from start to finish. This includes coordinating subcontractors, sourcing materials, ensuring codes and regulations are met, and ensuring the project stays on budget and on schedule. They often handle residential renovations, new home builds, and larger commercial projects. Hiring a general contractor ensures expert supervision and streamlines communication, helping ensure the job is completed efficiently and professionally.

The cost of hiring general contractors can vary widely depending on the scale of the project. On average:

  • Bathroom renovation: $10,000–$25,000
  • Kitchen remodeling: $15,000–$50,000
  • Home additions: $30,000–$150,000
  • Building a new home: $150,000–$500,000+

Keep in mind these ranges are approximate and subject to factors like location, materials, and complexity of the project. It's always advisable to get detailed estimates from multiple contractors to compare pricing and services.

Finding licensed general contractors in Shelter Island Heights involves several reliable methods:

  • Online directories: Use platforms like HomeAdvisor or Angie's List.
  • Local building departments: Contact your city or county building department for lists of licensed professionals.
  • Referrals: Ask friends, family, or neighbors for recommendations.

Make sure to verify their license through a trusted authority, such as your state’s licensing board or local contractor registry. Hiring licensed professionals ensures compliance with codes and regulations.

Here are key questions to ask when speaking with general contractors:

  1. Are you licensed and insured?
  2. Can you provide references or examples of past work?
  3. What’s your timeline for this project?
  4. Will you handle permits and inspections?
  5. Do you offer a warranty on your work?

These questions help assess their qualifications, experience, and reliability. Be thorough in your evaluation, as this can prevent issues down the road.

To avoid scams, follow these guidelines:

  • Verify licenses: Confirm the contractor holds current licensing from a trusted authority, such as your state’s licensing board.
  • Get contracts in writing: Never agree to verbal deals.
  • Avoid large upfront payments: Legitimate contractors follow payment schedules tied to milestones.
  • Check references: Speak directly to past clients about their experiences.
  • Trust your instincts: If something feels off, or the contractor is overly pushy, reconsider.

Taking these precautions helps ensure you hire a reputable professional for your project.

Contractor estimates typically factor in:

  • Material costs: Quality and quantity of materials required.
  • Labor charges: Skilled labor fees, including subcontractors.
  • Project complexity: Scope, design details, and unique challenges.
  • Permitting fees: Costs for pulling necessary permits from the relevant authorities.
  • Timeline: Longer projects may have higher labor costs.

Always request itemized estimates and clarify what’s included, so you can make informed comparisons across contractors.

Project timelines depend on the scope and type of work. Here are general estimates:

  • Small renovations (e.g., bathroom remodels): 4–8 weeks
  • Medium renovations (e.g., kitchen remodels): 8–12 weeks
  • Home additions: 3–6 months
  • New home construction: 6–12+ months

Factors like availability of materials, weather, and contractor schedules can impact timelines. Discuss expected completion dates and potential delays upfront to minimize surprises.

General contractors should hold proper licensing from state or local authorities, depending on their location. Licensing ensures they meet local building codes and safety standards. Many states also require insurance for liability and workers’ compensation. For additional credibility, contractors may pursue certifications like LEED accreditation for sustainable construction or CGP (Certified Green Professional) credentials. Learn more about requirements from trusted resources like National Association of Home Builders.

To set realistic expectations, consider:

  • Budget: Factor in local material and labor costs specific to Shelter Island Heights.
  • Timeline: Account for weather conditions and permit processing times in your area.
  • Scope: Be clear and detailed about your project goals upfront.
  • Communication: Have regular check-ins with your contractor to stay updated.

Remember, unforeseen issues may arise, so flexibility is key. Working closely with a licensed contractor experienced in Shelter Island Heights can help ensure smoother project execution.

Signs of a reputable contractor include:

  • Strong reviews: Positive customer feedback on platforms like Google, Yelp, or industry websites.
  • Transparent communication: Clear responses to questions about licenses, scheduling, and pricing.
  • References: Willingness to provide references from past clients.
  • Detailed contracts: Well-written agreements outlining scope, costs, and timelines.
  • Longevity: Years of experience in the industry often indicate reliability.

Always perform thorough research before signing a contract to confirm the contractor’s reputation and credentials.

Reviews for General Contractors

Basement Rescue in Days
Our basement flooded after a big storm, and I was overwhelmed at the thought of repairs. Within 24 hours of posting my issue, I had quotes from three experienced contractors. The one I hired tackled everything in less than a week, and it came in under budget. Feels great to have my space (and sanity) restored.
Emily R.
Ratings icon
Fast Fix, Big Savings
My deck was dangerously unstable, and I dreaded the cost of a full rebuild. The contractor I found through this service reinforced everything for a fraction of the replacement estimate! Now it's safe for family cookouts, and I saved over $2,000.
Paul H.
Ratings icon
A New Look, Stress-Free
Our living room remodel was stuck because I couldn’t find the right pro I could trust in Pittsburgh. This platform connected me with a general contractor who worked around my schedule and finished the job early. The best part? No hassles, and I finally enjoy coming home to a space that feels like 'me'.
Kim S.
Ratings icon

Why Hire General Contractors on The Builder Market?

Find Top-Rated General Contractors Near You

Related Services Near You

Learn More about Our Contributors

Maria Vierra avatar

Maria VierraEditor

Maria Vierra is the lead designer at Vierra Fine Homes, bringing over two decades of experience in high-end residential design and construction. Her expertise and attention to detail ensure every project meets the highest standards of excellence, blending functionality with aesthetic appeal.

Brett Taylor avatar

Brett TaylorAuthor

Brett Taylor is the co-founder of The Builder Market and a visionary entrepreneur in the home services and construction industries. With a passion for innovation, Brett has played a pivotal role in revolutionizing how professionals and homeowners connect and collaborate.

This page was last updated on Dec 2, 2025, 11:42:55 PM