Top-Rated New Home Builders Near You in Shelter Island Heights, NY

Accurate Building Inc.

Accurate Building Inc. has been in business for over 15 years, providing custom homes and professional remodeling and renovations of exceptional quality at competitive prices. Accurate Building Inc. is all about results! Our experienced team will focus on your plans and take you through a step by step process to create the home of your dreams. Our philosophy is meeting project timelines and customer expectations for a service standard that compares to none. Our innovative projects are always keeping the com

Read more about Accurate Building Inc.

Gottesman Construction

Fine Custom Home Builder Residential new construction

Read more about Gottesman Construction

CRC SOLUTIONS INC

The success of a new construction project depends on the talent and dedication of the tradespeople whose job it is to bring the project to life. CRC SOLUTIONS INC. has a clear mission that's been driving its success - and the success of its clients - for years. Our goals can be summed up in one simple statement: "Flexibility, innovation, results - for a lasting partnership." That's the guiding principle behind CRC SOLUTIONS INC.'s approach to doing business. With many years of experience in local a

Read more about CRC SOLUTIONS INC

FAIRFIELD HOMES, INC

Fairfield Homes is an award winning design-build firm specializing in affordable custom homes serving the North and Northwest Suburbs of Chicago, IL. Each home is designed to improve your lifestyle and positively impact the surrounding neighborhood. We build in established neighborhoods by responsibly preserving existing infrastructure, so each sidewalk, tree and park retains the character it has inherited over the years. Revitalizing Houses Typical houses can last fifty or more years. However, the compon

Read more about FAIRFIELD HOMES, INC

Barrett Builders X, LLC
Calatlantic Homes At The Hammocks At Mingo

CalAtlantic Homes, one of the nation’s largest and most respected homebuilders, offers well-crafted homes in thoughtfully designed communities that meet the desires of customers across the homebuilding spectrum. With a 50-year history, CalAtlantic has a trusted reputation for quality craftsmanship, an outstanding customer experience and exceptional architectural design. Learn more about our first-rate communities from coast to coast.

Read more about Calatlantic Homes At The Hammocks At Mingo

Cocoa Beach Vacation Homes

Vacation Rental & Home sharing This three bedrooms, two baths, two car garage single family home (Sleeps 4-6) A very well maintained rental home in Merritt Island, a Friendly Boaters Community with private backyard pool!!!!

Read more about Cocoa Beach Vacation Homes

Coastal Living Builders

Coastal Living Builders is the Hilton Head Island and Bluffton area’s source for innovative and creative building construction whether it be for a new home or renovation. We provide a personal “one-on-one” communication with the client from concept to final execution. We take immense pride in our work and look forward to working with you to create a home that you will be proud of. We will only be satisfied if you love to live in the home as we would.

Read more about Coastal Living Builders

Brookwood Estates

Benchmark Homes is proud to present Brookwood Estates, a sprawling 19-acre residential community with 44 premium home sites located in Sterling Heights, Michigan. Less than a mile away from Troy Beaumont Hospital, feeding into the nationally-acclaimed Utica Community School District and offering meticulously crafted homes built by a quality-driven building company, Brookwood Estates is a unique opportunity to call a truly premier community home.

Read more about Brookwood Estates

Capital Homes, Inc.

Capital Homes is a well established custom homebuilder that has built stylish, affordable custom single-family residences in the northwest suburbs of Chicago for the past 17 years. We specialize in building what we call "Cluster Communities", which are created by taking older homes or vacant lots and developing a new, vibrant neighborhood with well-designed, built-to-suit, energy-efficient homes. We also build single lot custom homes utilizing modifications of our existing model plan group or build full cus

Read more about Capital Homes, Inc.

About New Home Builders in Shelter Island Heights, NY

Building a custom home in Shelter Island Heights is an exciting journey that requires careful planning and expertise to navigate the area’s unique challenges. As experienced new home builders, we understand the complexities of constructing homes in this charming coastal community, where zoning regulations, environmental considerations, and local permitting requirements play a vital role in every project. Whether you’re envisioning a modern retreat or a timeless traditional design, we’re here to guide you through the process and bring your vision to life.

Shelter Island Heights presents specific challenges for new home construction, including strict zoning laws and regulations enforced by the City of Shelter Island Heights Planning and Development Department. Building in designated flood zones or hillside areas often requires extensive site planning reviews, land grading, and soil assessments to ensure long-term stability and compliance with local codes. Additionally, wildfire-resistant materials and energy-efficient designs are essential considerations for new builds in this region, reflecting both state mandates and local architectural standards.

Custom home construction in Shelter Island Heights typically ranges from $200 to $500 per square foot, depending on factors like lot conditions, building materials, and design complexity. Popular neighborhoods such as Silver Beach and Montclair Heights are seeing increased demand for custom homes, offering breathtaking views and proximity to Shelter Island’s natural beauty. Let us help you navigate the permitting timelines, inspections, and site-specific challenges to create the home you’ve always dreamed of in Shelter Island Heights.

New Home Builders FAQs

The cost of building a new home can vary widely depending on factors like location, size, materials, and design complexity. Nationally, the typical range is between $100 and $200 per square foot for standard construction. Custom homes and luxury builds can cost upwards of $300 per square foot or more. For example, a 2,000-square-foot home could cost between $200,000 and $600,000 to construct.

Factors that influence cost include:

  • Land preparation: Clearing and grading the lot can add thousands of dollars.
  • Material choices: High-end finishes will significantly increase costs.
  • Labor: Labor rates fluctuate depending on the region and demand.
  • Permits and fees: Typically $5,000–$10,000 depending on the local jurisdiction.

For the most accurate estimate, consult with local builders and request multiple quotes.

On average, building a new home in Shelter Island Heights takes between six months and a year. However, the timeline can vary depending on several factors, including the size of the home, weather conditions, local permitting processes, and the complexity of the design.

Here’s a rough breakdown of typical phases:

  1. Planning and design (1–3 months): Finalizing blueprints, budgets, and permits.
  2. Site preparation (1–2 weeks): Clearing the lot and laying the foundation.
  3. Construction (4–8 months): Framing, plumbing, electrical, and interior finishes.
  4. Inspections and finalization (1–2 months): Meeting local building codes and completing final touches.

Delays are common in the home-building process, so it’s important to work with experienced builders who provide realistic timelines.

When hiring a new home builder, consider the following factors:

  • Reputation: Check online reviews, testimonials, and references.
  • Experience: Look for builders with a portfolio of completed homes similar to what you’re envisioning.
  • Licensing and insurance: Verify that the builder is licensed and insured in your area.
  • Transparency: Ensure they provide detailed, itemized estimates and contracts.
  • Communication: Builders who are responsive and clear in their communication will save you headaches.

A good builder will also be upfront about potential challenges and help guide you through the process. Never skip doing your homework!

To confirm if a new home builder in Shelter Island Heights is licensed and insured, start by:

  1. Checking with your state or local licensing board. Most states maintain an online database of licensed contractors. Visit their website or call for details.
  2. Asking the builder directly for proof of licensure and insurance. They should provide a copy of their credentials upon request.
  3. Verifying their general liability and workers' compensation insurance. This protects you in case of property damage or worker injuries on site.

For trusted information, check your state’s licensing board. For example, the National Association of Home Builders (NAHB) offers resources to ensure your builder meets professional standards: NAHB Resource.

To choose the right builder, ask questions like:

  • How long have you been building homes?
  • Can I see examples of your work or visit any completed homes?
  • Are you licensed and insured to operate in this state?
  • What’s included in your base pricing? Are there additional costs I should know about?
  • How will you keep me updated during the project?
  • Can you provide references from past clients?
  • What is the warranty on the home after completion?

A good builder will provide clear answers and offer documentation where necessary. Take notes and compare responses before making your decision.

Red flags to look out for when hiring a new home builder include:

  • Lack of references: A reputable builder should be able to provide a list of satisfied clients.
  • No license or insurance: Never work with unlicensed or uninsured contractors.
  • Pressure to pay upfront: Reputable builders usually require staged payments but never demand large sums before work begins.
  • Unclear contracts: The contract should outline all expenses, timelines, and materials clearly.
  • Negative online reviews: Consistently poor feedback is a major warning.

It's crucial to trust your instincts. If something feels off during your initial interaction, consider other options.

New home construction estimates generally include a detailed breakdown of costs, such as:

  • Material costs: Lumber, concrete, roofing, and finishes.
  • Labor costs: Payments to subcontractors like plumbers and electricians.
  • Permit fees: Costs to meet local building regulations.
  • Contingency allowance: A buffer for unexpected costs, often 5–10% of the estimate.

Request multiple estimates from different builders and ensure that they include similar specifications. This will help you compare pricing accurately. Also, avoid underestimations by providing clear and complete information upfront about your desired home features and finishes.

Most new home builders offer warranties to ensure the quality of their work. These typically include:

  • Structural warranty (10 years): Covers major structural defects such as foundation or framing issues.
  • Systems warranty (2–5 years): Covers essential systems like plumbing, electrical, and HVAC.
  • Workmanship warranty (1 year): Covers issues with finishes like paint, flooring, or cabinetry.

Always review the warranty agreement carefully and ask for clarifications. Some builders also provide third-party warranties for additional credibility and assurance.

Yes, most new home builders offer varying levels of customization. Options typically include:

  • Pre-designed plans: Builders may have a catalog of layouts to choose from, with minor customization options.
  • Semi-custom homes: Adjustments like changing room sizes, finishes, or adding features.
  • Fully custom builds: Clients work with architects and builders to design their home from scratch.

Customization options often come with higher costs and longer timelines, so discuss these factors in detail with your builder before committing.

Some builders handle permitting as part of their services, but it’s essential to confirm. The building permits process involves adhering to local codes and usually includes zoning approvals, environmental checks, and inspections.

Before finalizing the contract, ask:

  • Who is responsible for obtaining permits?
  • Are permit costs included in the estimate?
  • What happens if there’s a permit-related delay?

Permits are crucial for ensuring the safety and legality of your new home. Experienced builders will navigate this process seamlessly, saving you time and stress.

Reviews for New Home Builders

Built My Dream Home Fast
We needed a reliable builder for our forever home in Raleigh, NC. After connecting with professionals through the service, we picked a pro who finished construction three weeks ahead of schedule and under budget. Moving in stress-free saved us time and a bundle!
Jessica P.
Ratings icon
Easy Approval Process
I had concerns about navigating permits for my new home, but the contractor I found through this site handled everything seamlessly. They communicated with city officials, sped up approvals, and broke ground within days. The entire experience was a weight off my shoulders.
Mark L.
Ratings icon
Affordable Custom Build
Finding someone who could stick to my budget and still offer custom options felt impossible until I used this service. The builder we chose added design upgrades that stayed within our limits, and the result is a gorgeous home that feels totally 'us.'
Amy R.
Ratings icon

Why Hire New Home Builders on The Builder Market?

Find Top-Rated New Home Builders Near You

Related Services Near You

Learn More about Our Contributors

Maria Vierra avatar

Maria VierraEditor

Maria Vierra is the lead designer at Vierra Fine Homes, bringing over two decades of experience in high-end residential design and construction. Her expertise and attention to detail ensure every project meets the highest standards of excellence, blending functionality with aesthetic appeal.

Brett Taylor avatar

Brett TaylorAuthor

Brett Taylor is the co-founder of The Builder Market and a visionary entrepreneur in the home services and construction industries. With a passion for innovation, Brett has played a pivotal role in revolutionizing how professionals and homeowners connect and collaborate.

This page was last updated on Dec 5, 2025, 5:54:35 PM